You are at a wedding, a funeral or a family dinner. Someone crosses themselves, or someone mentions their Bible study group, and you realize you could not explain the difference if someone asked you. Or you are dating someone from the other tradition and you want to understand them well, not just win an argument at Thanksgiving.

The short answer: Catholics and Protestants are both Christians. They share the center of the faith, and they differ on how the church is led, where final authority lies, how many sacraments there are, and how to describe the way salvation works. Each tradition has its own reasons, and each would describe itself differently from how the other describes it. So here we try to describe each one the way its own members would.

Both are big families. Protestantism in particular is many traditions, not one, so any short summary has exceptions. If a Catholic or Protestant friend tells you it is a bit different in their church, they are probably right.

What Catholics and Protestants share

Start here, because it is easy to forget. Both traditions say the Nicene Creed, an ancient statement of faith from the fourth century. It says there is one God in three persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit. It says Jesus is fully God and fully human, that he was crucified, rose again, and will come again. Both read the Bible as God's word. Both baptize, pray, sing, care for the poor, and gather on Sundays.

For both, the heart of it is Jesus. Most of the differences below are about how to follow him, not whether to.

Ephesians 4:4–6

"There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to one hope when you were called; one Lord, one faith, one baptism; one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all."

Paul names what Christians have in common: one Lord, one faith, one God.

Authority: the Bible, tradition and the Pope

Catholics believe God's truth comes through Scripture and Sacred Tradition together. Tradition means the teaching the apostles handed down and the church has kept, such as the creeds and the worship of the early church. Catholics believe the bishops, united with the Pope, have the job of interpreting both faithfully. The Pope, the Bishop of Rome, is seen as the successor of the apostle Peter and as a sign of unity for the whole church. Catholics often point to Jesus' words to Peter in Matthew 16.

Most Protestants hold that Scripture is the final authority, and that church traditions are valuable but must be tested against the Bible. This is often called "Scripture alone," from the Latin sola scriptura. Protestants read the same passage about Peter differently. Many understand the "rock" to be Peter's confession of faith, or Christ himself. Protestant churches have no single human head. They are led by pastors, elders, congregations or regional bishops, depending on the tradition.

Each side can point to a verse. Catholics often point to Paul telling believers to hold to the traditions he taught. Protestants often point to Paul saying all Scripture is useful for teaching and correcting. Both verses are in the Bible, and both traditions take them seriously.

Matthew 16:18

"And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build My church, and the gates of Hades will not prevail against it."

Catholics see Peter's special role here, while many Protestants read the rock as Peter's faith or as Christ.

2 Thessalonians 2:15

"Therefore, brothers, stand firm and cling to the traditions we taught you, whether by speech or by letter."

Catholics point to this when they say teaching passed on by word matters alongside the written Bible.

2 Timothy 3:16

"All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for instruction, for conviction, for correction, and for training in righteousness,"

Protestants point to this when they say Scripture is the standard everything else is measured by.

Worship, sacraments, priests, Mary and the saints

A sacrament is a visible act that Christians believe God uses to give his grace. Catholics count seven: baptism, the Eucharist (communion), confirmation, reconciliation (confessing sins to a priest), anointing of the sick, marriage and holy orders (ordination). At Mass, Catholics believe the bread and wine become the body and blood of Christ. Priests serve in Christ's name, and many Catholic services follow a set order of prayers and readings that has been used for centuries.

Most Protestants practice two: baptism and the Lord's Supper (communion). Some call them ordinances rather than sacraments. Beliefs about communion range from Christ being really present, as in Lutheran churches, to a meaningful remembrance, as in many Baptist churches. Protestants stress what they call the priesthood of all believers, the idea that every Christian may come to God directly through Jesus. Pastors teach and lead, but are not seen as a necessary go-between. Protestant worship ranges from quiet and traditional to loud and contemporary.

Mary and the saints are another difference. Catholics honor Mary as the mother of Jesus and ask her and the saints to pray for them, much as you might ask a friend to pray for you. They say they honor the saints and worship only God. Protestants also honor Mary as a model of faith, but generally pray only to God, out of concern that every prayer should go straight to him. Both sides agree that Mary was a young woman who said yes to God.

Luke 1:48

"For He has looked with favor on the humble state of His servant. From now on all generations will call me blessed."

Mary says this herself, and both traditions honor her in their own ways.

Salvation: grace, faith and works

Both traditions say salvation is a gift from God through Jesus, not something anyone earns. The difference is mostly in emphasis and in how the pieces are described.

Catholics teach that God's grace is received through faith and through the sacraments, and that faith is lived out in love and good works as a person grows in holiness. Protestants, following Martin Luther, emphasize that we are made right with God through faith alone, and that good works are the fruit of that gift, not the cause of it. In 1999 the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation signed a joint statement saying they share a basic understanding of this, though some differences in wording remain.

Each side has verses it leans on. Catholics often cite James, and Protestants often cite Ephesians. If you want to go deeper on how Christians put these together, we have a page on whether we are saved by faith or works.

Ephesians 2:8–9

"For it is by grace you have been saved through faith, and this not from yourselves; it is the gift of God, not by works, so that no one can boast."

Protestants point to this to say salvation is a pure gift, received by faith.

James 2:24

"As you can see, a man is justified by his deeds and not by faith alone."

Catholics point to this to say real faith shows up in what a person does.

How the two families came about, and how to talk across them

For the first thousand years the church was largely one body, though it had its disagreements. In 1054 the churches of the East and West separated. The Eastern family is called the Orthodox Church. It shares much with Catholics, including sacraments and honoring Mary, but does not recognize the Pope's authority.

In 1517 a German monk and Catholic priest named Martin Luther posted a list of concerns about church practices, especially the selling of indulgences, which were payments tied to the forgiveness of penalties for sin. What began as a call for reform became the Reformation, and new churches formed: Lutheran, Reformed, Anglican, and later Baptist, Methodist and many others. Painful wars and cruelty followed on both sides, and many Catholics and Protestants today openly regret that history.

One practical note: Catholic Bibles include seven extra books in the Old Testament that most Protestant Bibles do not. The question about why the Bible has 66 books, linked below, explains how that came about.

You do not have to settle all this to be kind about it. A good question is "How do you understand that?" and then listening to the whole answer before replying. Most people hold their tradition because it is where they met God, and it is easier to learn from someone who feels heard.

If you are choosing between churches, or you are in a mixed marriage, take your time. Visit, ask questions, and pray about it. You can love Jesus well in more than one place.

"You can ask your honest questions without being pushed toward a side."

In Bible Voice you can ask Scripture chat anything about what the Bible says, any hour of the day, and get an answer with real verses and no judgment. Passages can also be explained in plain language in the voice you choose: Gen Z, Millennial, Gen X or Boomer.

Hear it in your voice

For reflection

A few questions to carry

You do not need to pick a side tonight. These questions are just for thinking.

  • What do I already share with the Christian I am trying to understand?
  • Which difference matters most to me, and have I heard how the other side explains it in their own words?
  • Who could I ask a genuine question this week, with the goal of understanding and not arguing?

Prayer: God, thank you that we all belong to Jesus. Help me hold what I believe with honesty and hold other people with kindness. Teach me to listen well, to ask good questions, and to love the people I disagree with. Amen.